Back to E-commerce Tips

The Best Products to Upsell After Checkout, and How to Find Yours

E-commerce Tips
The Best Products to Upsell After Checkout, and How to Find Yours

The offer you show after checkout matters more than the design, the copy or the discount. A beautiful page with the wrong product gets a polite "no thanks" from almost everyone. So which are the best products to upsell, and how do you find them in your own catalog?

This guide gives you a simple test any product can be run through, ideas for six common kinds of stores, and a way to find your strongest candidates in the orders you already have.


What makes a product a good upsell after checkout

After checkout, the buyer has already decided. They're not browsing anymore, they're about to look at their order confirmation. A product that works here has to make sense in a few seconds. Run each candidate through these six questions.

1. Does it belong with what they just bought?

Relevance comes first. Shopify's own UX guidance for these offers says to "present relevant products by tailoring upsell offers to the shopping behaviors and preferences of customers" (Shopify UX guidelines). A phone case after a phone is obvious. A phone case after a scarf is noise.

2. Is it cheap next to the order?

The buyer just made their main decision. A small add-on feels like a small extra; something that costs as much as the order feels like starting over. Look for products priced well below your typical order.

3. Will they need it anyway?

The strongest upsells are things the buyer would have to come back for: refills, spare parts, batteries, filters, care products. Saying yes saves them a second order.

4. Can it ship in the same parcel?

After-checkout offers usually travel with the original order, which is why free shipping on them is easy to justify. Small, light products that fit the box you're already sending are ideal. Bulky or fragile items that need their own shipment cost you more and arrive separately.

5. Is the choice simple?

A product with two sizes is easy. A product with 40 color and size combinations is a decision the buyer won't make in a few seconds. If an offer has variants, keep the list short, and let the buyer pick theirs rather than guessing for them.

6. Do you have the stock and the margin?

You'll likely offer a discount, so the product needs room for it. And it needs to be in stock: an offer for something you can't ship is worse than no offer.

A product that passes all six is a strong first offer. One that fails on relevance or price usually isn't worth testing.


The best products to upsell, by type of store

Every catalog is different, but the same patterns turn up again and again. Some starting points:

  • Coffee and tea: a second bag of the same blend, paper filters, a reusable cup, a sampler of another roast.
  • Beauty and skincare: a travel size of what they bought, a matching cleanser or serum, cotton pads, a refill pouch.
  • Apparel: socks, a belt, a matching scarf or hat, a fabric care spray, another color of the same basic tee.
  • Electronics: a case, a screen protector, a charging cable, a spare battery, a cleaning kit.
  • Pets: treats, a chew toy, poop bags, a refill of the food they just ordered.
  • Home and kitchen: a cleaning or care product for what they bought, spare parts, a smaller matching item like napkins with a tablecloth.

Notice what's missing: big-ticket items, unrelated bestsellers and anything that needs a long explanation. Those belong on your product pages and in your emails, not in the minute after payment. For full offers built around products like these, see these post-purchase upsell examples.


When to offer the same product again

Most stores avoid offering what the buyer just bought, and for many products that's right. Nobody needs a second sofa.

For products people use up or give away, it's often the best offer you have. A second bag of coffee, another candle as a gift, an extra pack of the socks they just picked: "add another one at a better price" needs no guessing about what else they might want, and it applies to every product in your store with one rule.


How to find your best upsell products in your own data

You don't need a data team for this. Your order history already shows what people buy together.

  1. Start with your top five products by orders. These are the orders your upsell will see most often.
  2. Open recent orders that contain each one and note the other items in them. Products that keep showing up next to a bestseller are your best candidates.
  3. Look at what customers buy on their second order. If people who buy a grinder come back for filters, offer filters right after the grinder.
  4. Check your returns. Leave out products that are often returned. Upselling them only creates more returns.
  5. Run the six questions above on your shortlist, and pick one product per bestseller.

Then set up a general offer for everything else: a low-priced, broadly useful add-on that suits most orders. Between targeted offers for your bestsellers and one general offer, you cover most of your orders without a long list of rules.

For more ideas on how the offer itself can look, see the post-purchase upsell guide. Once you have the products, raising order value after checkout covers pricing, follow-ups and how to measure the result.


Test, then keep what works

Your first pick is a guess, even a well-informed one. Watch two numbers for each product: how often buyers accept it, and how often they return it. Swap out a product that few buyers accept, and drop one that comes back often. Change one thing at a time, so you know what made the difference.


Picking products in Elite Post Purchase

In Elite Post Purchase, each offer screen has a Product source with three options. Choose products lets you pick up to 10 products and the variants buyers can choose from. Buy again offers the buyer another one of what they just bought, at your discount, with one screen for every product. EliteAI™, in beta, picks a product for each order from what your customers tend to buy together. Choose the products to offer and Offer the product the buyer just bought explain each setup. Conditions such as Purchased products or Purchased collections then match each offer to the right orders.

It's free for your first 50 orders a month, then from $7/mo (Essentials). See features and pricing.

Ready to put the right product in front of every buyer? Pick one companion for your best seller, run it through the six questions, and let your buyers tell you if you got it right.

E-commerceShopifyUpsellingPost-PurchaseProduct Strategy