Increase Average Order Value on Shopify After Checkout

Most advice on how to increase average order value on Shopify happens before the buyer pays: bundles on the product page, a free shipping bar in the cart, add-ons in checkout. They can work, but every one of them asks the buyer to think about more while they're still deciding whether to buy at all.
There's a second window that most stores leave empty: the minute right after payment. The order is placed, the buyer is still on your site, and one well-chosen offer can make the order bigger without putting the first sale at risk. This guide covers how to use that window, what to put in it, and how to tell whether it's working.
Why increase average order value after checkout
Average order value (AOV) is your revenue divided by your number of orders. You raise it by getting each buyer to spend a bit more, which is usually cheaper than finding a new buyer.
The catch with pre-checkout tactics is that they compete with the purchase itself. A bundle widget, a cross-sell carousel and a "you might also like" row all add choices, and every choice is a chance for a hesitant buyer to stop and leave.
After checkout, that trade-off disappears:
- The first order is already paid. Whatever the buyer does with your offer, the original sale stands.
- The buyer has just said yes to you. Adding a small, related item is a much smaller step than the decision they just made.
- There's no new checkout. On Shopify's post-purchase page, the buyer adds the offer with one click, charged to the payment method they just used.
So the after-checkout window doesn't replace your cart and product page tactics. It adds a place to raise order value that costs you nothing when the buyer says no. The one-click upsell guide explains the mechanics of that click in detail.
Two places to add value after payment
Shopify gives you two spots between "Pay now" and the end of the visit:
- The post-purchase page. Shopify describes it as content shown "after your customer completes their payment, but before they're presented with their order confirmation page" (Shopify Help Center). One click adds the offer to the order.
- The thank-you page. The order confirmation itself. An offer here is added to the same order too, but the buyer pays for it in a second, short checkout step.
Not every order reaches the post-purchase page. Shopify skips it for some payment methods, such as wallets and pay-later services, and for orders in another currency (Shopify's developer docs). An offer on the thank-you page can reach many of those buyers instead, so the two work well together: post-purchase first, thank-you page as the backup.
Five ways to raise order value after checkout
1. Offer the obvious companion
The best after-checkout offer is something the buyer will need anyway: a case for the phone, filters for the coffee machine, a second set of sheets for the new duvet. If they'd have to come back for it next week, adding it now saves them the trip.
Start with your best-selling product and ask what people who buy it usually buy next. That's your first offer.
2. Keep the price small next to the order
The buyer just made their main decision. A second decision of the same size is a much harder sell. An add-on that costs a fraction of the order feels like a small extra; one that doubles the order feels like a new purchase.
If your orders vary a lot in size, match the offer to the order. A small accessory for smaller orders, a premium upgrade for larger ones.
3. Give a reason to add it now
"You might also like" works in a store. After checkout, the buyer needs a reason to add the item now instead of later. The two most natural ones:
- A discount that only exists here, shown next to the original price.
- Free shipping, because the item travels in the parcel that's already going out.
Both are honest, and both explain why this offer is better than ordering the same thing next month.
4. Offer more of what they just bought
For products people use up or give away, "add another one" is often the strongest offer: a second bag of coffee, an extra pack of socks, another candle as a gift. It needs no guessing about what else the buyer wants.
5. Follow up a "no" and a "yes"
A decline isn't the end. A downsell after a "no" offers a cheaper alternative or a better deal on a smaller version. A buyer who says "yes" has shown they're open to more, so a second small offer can follow. The downsell examples show what to put after a decline.
Keep it short. Shopify's UX guidance recommends "a maximum of three consecutive upsell offers" (Shopify UX guidelines). The buyer came to see their confirmation, not a catalog.
Don't win order value and lose trust
The page after payment comes right after the buyer trusted you with their card. Pressure tactics there cost more than they earn:
- Show the full price, including shipping and tax, before the buyer clicks.
- Make declining easy. A plain "No thanks" link, no guilt-trip wording.
- Only use a countdown if the offer really expires.
- Don't offer what they just bought, unless it's something they'll use up or give away.
A buyer who feels tricked into a second item is a buyer who returns it, or doesn't come back.
How to measure the lift in order value
Shopify's own AOV figure is a useful baseline, but read its definition before you judge an upsell by it. Since 2023, Shopify calculates AOV from gross sales minus discounts, "excluding any adjustments made to the order after it was created" (Shopify changelog). Items added to an order after checkout may not move that number the way you expect.
So track the after-checkout offers on their own:
- Acceptance rate: offers accepted divided by orders that saw an offer.
- Revenue added: the total value of accepted offers per month.
- Returns on upsold items: if buyers send them back, the offer isn't a good match.
- Reach: how many of your orders see an offer at all. If it's low, check which payment methods your buyers use.
Change one thing at a time, such as the product, the discount or the targeting, and give each version enough orders before you compare.
Raising order value after checkout with Elite Post Purchase
Elite Post Purchase is our app for both of these pages. You build flows with up to three offers and downsells, give each product a percentage or fixed discount and free or paid shipping, and use Conditions such as Order total or Purchased collections to show each order the right offer. A flow can add a thank-you page offer as a backup for buyers who got no post-purchase page; Show an offer on the thank-you page explains how. The Analytics page shows acceptance and upsell revenue for each page, as covered in Read your analytics.
It's free for your first 50 orders a month, then from $7/mo (Essentials). See features and pricing, or start with the post-purchase upsell guide for the bigger picture.
Ready to make the minute after payment count? Pick one companion for your best seller, give it a fair discount, and see how many buyers add it.